How do we view the Eucharist?
For the first thousand years of Christian history, when the Church was visibly
one and undivided, the holy gifts of the Body and Blood of Christ were received
as just that: His Body and Blood. The Church confessed this was a mystery: The
bread is truly His Body, and that which is in the cup is truly His Blood, but
one cannot say how they become so.
The eleventh and twelfth centuries brought on the scholastic era, the Age of Reason in the West. The Roman Church, which had become separated from the
Orthodox Church in A.D. 1054, was pressed by the rationalists to define how the
transformation takes place. They answered with the word transubstantiation,
meaning a change of substance. The elements are no longer bread and wine;
they
are physically changed into flesh and blood. The sacrament, which only faith
can comprehend, was subjected to a philosophical definition. This second view of
the
Eucharist was unknown to the ancient Church.
Not surprisingly, one of the points of disagreement between Rome and the
sixteenth-century reformers was the issue of transubstantiation. Unable to
accept this explanation of the sacrament, the radical reformers, who were
rationalists themselves, took up the opposite point of view: the gifts are
nothing but bread and wine, period. They only represent Christ's Body and
Blood; they have no spiritual reality. This third, symbol-only view helps
explain the infrequency with which some Protestants partake of the Eucharist.
The Scriptures and the Eucharist
What do the Scriptures teach concerning the Eucharist?
(1) Jesus said, 'This is My body ... this is My blood" (Luke 22:19, 20). There
is never a statement that these gifts merely symbolise His Body and Blood.
Critics have charged that Jesus also said of Himself, "I am the door" (John
10:7), and He certainly is not a seven-foot wooden plank. The flaw in that
argument is obvious: at no time has the Church ever believed He was a literal
door. But she has always believed the consecrated gifts of bread and wine are
truly His Body and Blood.
(2) In the New Testament, those who received Christ's Body and Blood unworthily
are said to bring condemnation upon themselves. "For this reason many are weak
and sick among you, and many sleep" (literally, "are dead"; 1 Cor. 11:30).
A mere symbol, a quarterly reminder, could hardly have the power to cause sickness
and death!
(3) Historically, from the New Testament days on, the central act of worship,
the new apex of spiritual sacrifice, took place "on the first day of the week,
when the disciples came together to break bread" (Acts 20:7). The Eucharist
has always been that supreme act of thanksgiving and praise to God in His
Church.
From The Orthodox Study Bible
Copyright © 1993 by St. Athanasius Orthodox Academy
Recommended reading: "The Sacraments of the
Orthodox Church", Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America.
To: Previous Orthodox Articles
|